India’s Rise on the World Stage Under PM Modi: Mirage or Reality?


As India continues its journey on the global stage, a new report has stirred controversy by challenging the narrative of the country’s ascent under the leadership of Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Titled “India’s Rise on the World Stage: A Mirage,” the report raises provocative questions about the nature and sustainability of India’s purported rise, sparking debate and introspection about the country’s trajectory in the international arena. As analysts and policymakers grapple with the implications of these findings, the report prompts a critical examination of India’s place in the world and the factors shaping its global standing.

The report’s central thesis challenges the prevailing narrative of India’s rise as a global powerhouse, arguing that much of the progress touted by the government is illusory and fails to translate into tangible gains for the country and its citizens. While acknowledging certain achievements in areas such as economic growth, diplomatic outreach, and technological advancement, the report contends that these successes are overshadowed by persistent challenges and shortcomings that undermine India’s true potential on the world stage.

One of the key arguments put forth by the report is the discrepancy between India’s rhetoric of global leadership and its actual capacity to influence international affairs. Despite ambitious pronouncements of India’s emergence as a leading global power, the report points to a lack of substantive achievements in key areas such as foreign policy, strategic partnerships, and multilateral engagement. Moreover, it highlights instances where India’s diplomatic efforts have fallen short, such as the failure to secure permanent membership in the United Nations Security Council or to resolve longstanding disputes with neighboring countries.

Another critical aspect examined in the report is the gap between India’s economic growth and its impact on social development and human well-being. While India has made significant strides in economic indicators such as GDP growth and foreign direct investment, the report argues that these gains have not translated into commensurate improvements in areas such as poverty alleviation, healthcare, education, and gender equality. Persistent challenges such as income inequality, unemployment, and social unrest continue to hamper India’s quest for inclusive and sustainable development, casting doubt on the narrative of a rising economic powerhouse.

Furthermore, the report raises concerns about the erosion of democratic norms and institutions in India, citing instances of censorship, suppression of dissent, and attacks on civil liberties under the Modi government. While democracy has long been touted as one of India’s defining strengths, the report warns that the erosion of democratic values threatens to undermine the country’s credibility and influence on the world stage, tarnishing its reputation as a vibrant and pluralistic democracy.

In response to the report, supporters of the Modi government have pushed back against its conclusions, arguing that it fails to capture the full scope of India’s achievements and the complexities of its journey on the global stage. They point to initiatives such as Make in India, Digital India, and the International Solar Alliance as evidence of India’s commitment to innovation, entrepreneurship, and sustainable development. Moreover, they argue that India’s growing influence in forums such as the G20, BRICS, and the Quad reflects its expanding role as a key player in shaping global governance and addressing pressing challenges such as climate change, terrorism, and pandemic response.

However, critics of the government contend that these initiatives often fall short of their lofty aspirations, citing issues such as implementation challenges, bureaucratic red tape, and lack of inclusive growth. They argue that India’s rise on the world stage cannot be measured solely in terms of economic indicators or diplomatic posturing but must also account for the well-being and aspirations of its diverse population.

As India grapples with the findings of the report, it confronts fundamental questions about its identity, aspirations, and role in the world. While there is no denying India’s potential as a global leader, the path to realizing this vision remains fraught with challenges and uncertainties. As policymakers chart a course for India’s future, they must heed the lessons of the past and embrace a holistic approach that prioritizes inclusive development, democratic values, and responsible leadership on the world stage. Only then can India’s rise be truly transformative, leaving behind the mirage and embracing the reality of its rightful place in the community of nations.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here